Sunday, April 6, 2008

Religious Fanaticism and Poly-Behavioral Addiction

Surveys demo that faith and spiritualty drama a cardinal function in the lives of most of the population in human experience. Gallup (2004) establish that 59% of grownups countrywide say faith is a very of import portion of their lives. An further 26% of Americans state faith is fairly of import to them. Just 15% of respondents state faith is not very important. About two-thirds of Americans, 64%, belong to a Christian church or synagogue. The Negro spiritual and spiritual dimensions of civilization were establish to be among the most of import factors that construction person experience, beliefs, values, behavior, and unwellness (Browning et al., 1990 James, 1961 Krippner and Welch, 1992).

Researchers however, study that some people look to acquire fanatical about thier faith and develop maladaptive behaviors. Members of the American Psychological Association reported that at least one in six of their clients presented issues that affect faith or spiritualty (Shafranske and Maloney, 1990). In another study, 29% of psychologists agreed that spiritual issues are of import in the treatment of all or many of their clients (Bergin and Jensen, 1990, p. 3). Psychotherapy can sometimes be effectual in treating spiritual problems. Robert Robinson (1986) noted, "Some patients have got troublesome struggles about faith that could probably be resolved through the procedure of psychotherapy" (p.22).

Religious jobs can be as assorted and complex as mental wellness problems. One type of psychoreligious job affects patients who escalate their attachment to spiritual patterns and orthodoxy (Lukoff, Lu, and Nat Turner 1992, p. 677). Generally when people talk of habit-forming diseases they connote a medical problem. In the past few old age the term dependence have been used to qualify behaviours that spell beyond chemicals. Dr. Henry Martin Robert Lefever (1988) positions dependence as a "family disease" involving self-denial and caretaking, domination, and entry (p. ix). Gerald May (1988) states that dependence is a "state of compulsion, obsession, or preoccupation that enslaves a person's volition and desire" (p.14). Shaef (1987) defines dependence as "any procedure over which we are powerless" (p. 18). She splits dependences into two categories: matter dependences -alcohol, drugs, nicotine, food) and procedure dependences -money-accumulation, gambling, sex, work, worry, and religion.

Research in the country of spiritual dependence is deficient, however there were a few aged related to surveys establish in the literature. Simmonds (1977) studies that there is some grounds to bespeak that "religious people in general be given to exhibit dependence on some external beginning of gratification" (p. 114). Black and Greater London (1966) establish a high positive correlativity between the variables of obeisance to parents and state and indices of spiritual belief such as as Christian church attendance, belief in Supreme Being and supplication (p. 39). Goldsen, et al. (1960) showed that people who were more than spiritual consistently showed inclinations toward greater societal conformance than did the nonreligious, a determination consistent with the impression that spiritual people seek external approval. These consequences are supported by Fisherman (1964 p. 784), who reported that a measurement of societal blessing and faith were strongly associated. Religious people demo dependance not only on societal values, but also on other external agents. Duke (1964, p. 227) establish that Christian church attending indicated more than reactivity to the personal effects of a placebo. In a survey of 50 alcoholics, it was establish that those who were dependent on alcoholic beverage were more than likely to have got had a spiritual background (Walters, 1957, p. 405).

The few research surveys aforesaid look to propose that spiritual people develop a dependence on spiritual patterns for societal approval. Since spiritual people look to be describable in footing of relatively high degrees of dependence, it looks utile to borrow a conception suggested by Peele and Brodsky (1975)- that of "addiction." According to these authors dependence is "a person's fond regard to a sensation, an object, or another person... such as as to decrease his grasp of and ability to cover with other things in his environment, or in himself, so that he have go increasingly dependent on that experience as his lone beginning of gratification" (p. 168).

There are a assortment of definitions for the conception of spiritual addiction. Arterburn and Felton (1992) state that "when a individual is excessively devoted to something or resignations compulsively and habitually to something, that pathological and physiological dependence on a substance, relationship, or behaviour consequences in addiction" (p. 104). They bespeak that, "like any other addiction, the pattern of faith goes cardinal to every other facet of life...all human relationships germinate from the religion, and the dependence on the spiritual pattern and its members takes the demand for a dependence on God...the faith and those who pattern it then go the cardinal powerfulness for the nut who no longer is in touching with God" (p. 117).

Spirituality can also have got pathological facets to it. Sarah Vaughan (1991) studies that "the shadow side to a healthy hunt for integrity can be called dependence to spirituality" (p. 105). He bespeaks that this tin be establish among people who utilize spiritualty as a solution to jobs they are unwilling to face. Van-Kaam (1987) shows a point of view of dependence as a quasi spiritual or falsified spiritual presence. He describes that "an apprehension of the human relationship between spiritual presence and dependence lets possible dangers of receptiveness to be identified in order to recognize the existent value of true spiritual presence and the shame of its counterfeit, addiction" (p. 243). McKenzie (1991) discusses dependence as an unauthentic word form of Negro spiritual existence. He states that, "addiction is born of the human desire for transcendency which is often perverted or misplaced by societies that promote their members to seek ultimate significance in dimensions that have got no respect for the transcendent" (p. 325). Heise (1991, p. 11) researches the fundamentalistic Christian's concentrate on perfectionism, and it's possible part to an addition in dysfunctional individuals, household systems, and addictions.

Until recently, research in this country have primarily focused on spiritual cults. Estimates of the figure of cults scope from respective hundred to respective thousand, with a sum rank up to three million (Allen and Metoyer, 1988, p. 38 Melton, 1986). According to Margaret Singer, Ph.D., A psychologist specializing in cult phenomena, "the word cult depicts a powerfulness structure,...what really put a cult apart is that one individual have got announced himself to have some particular knowledge, and if he can convert others to allow him be in charge, he will share that knowledge" (Collins & Frantz, 1994, p. 30). The Jim Mother Jones People's Temple mass self-destruction have been documented in the news, and more than recently Saint David Koresh's Branch Davidian Christian cult. Cults, both destructive and benign, have got been with us in assorted pretenses since clip immemorial. Many psychologists and head-shrinkers have got got go enlightened about destructive cults in the course of study of their work with patients affected by the problem.

Within the past few years, however, traditional Church members have faced their compulsive behaviour and noxious beliefs. Doucette (1992) studies that "many people are waking up because they have got seen their spiritual leadership fall. Some research workers believe that the magnitude of the calamity of spiritual dependence and maltreatment was revealed by the television revivalist dirts documented in the news mass media which involved: Jim and Tammy Bakker Jimmy Swaggart and Oral Richard J. Roberts (Brand 1987, p. 82 C. Vann Woodward 1987, p. 68 and George S. Kaufman 1988, p. 37). These personal confessions have got exposed not only how these supposed work force of Supreme Being had betrayed people's trust, but how many of those who had been abused, betrayed, and bankrupted never seemed to inquiry what was happening and continued to back up these individuals.

Booth (1991) states that "the Bakker, Swaggart, and Richard J. Roberts dirts created a national intercession that served to disrupt the advancement of this unhealthy phenomenon" (p. 38). What had previously been viewed as fanaticism or zealotry increasingly began to be called spiritual dependence and spiritual abuse. Booth (1991) defines Negro spiritual dependence as "using God, a church, or a belief system as an flight from reality, or as a arm against ourselves or others in an effort to happen or elevate a sense of self-worth or well-being" (p. 38).

Other research workers utilize the footing spiritual and psychological maltreatment to depict the features of spiritual addiction. Enroth (1992) states that his book "Churches That Maltreatment is about people who have got been abused psychologically and spiritually in Christian churches and other Christian organizations" (p. 29). He describes that "unlike physical maltreatment that often consequences in bruised bodies, Negro Negro spiritual and pastorale maltreatment go forths cicatrixes on the mind and soul...the sexual perversion of powerfulness that we see in insulting Christian churches disrupts and splits families, Fosters unhealthy dependance of members on the leadership, and creates, ultimately, spiritual confusion in the lives of victims" (p. 29). The dirts involving television revivalists created a national intercession by bringing spiritual dependence and maltreatment too fold to place to be ignored. Those dirts spurred people to move and phone call for change.

During this period, I had the alone chance to carry on a literature reappraisal and study on the relatively newly recognized phenomenon of spiritual dependence within Christian Religion inch the State of Aloha State for my thesis while pursuing my physician of psychological science grade (Psy.D) in clinical psychology. After studying the symptoms, beliefs, and phases of spiritual dependence along with the features of religiously habit-forming organizations, I came to believe that having an intense religion or spiritual ferver is not equal to having a spiritual addiction. Most people experience healthy faith and a Negro spiritual life in which obeisance to Supreme Being is balanced with a freedom to function others in ways of individual experession.

I also discovered however, that Christian Christian church leadership in Aloha State that were self-appointed (not elected/ appointive by their church) significantly identified more than with spiritual habit-forming beliefs, symptoms and patterns compared to their counterparts.

Multiple Addictions

Compulsive pietism sometimes attaches to other dependences as the spiritual nut is seeking to decrease guiltiness and shame. Since it is impossible to anticipate treatment for one dependence to be good when other dependences co-exist, the initial curative intercession for any dependence necessitates to include an appraisal for other addictions. In my clinical practice, I have got got noticed a important correlativity between spiritual dependence and other matter maltreatment and behavioural dependences such as as chemical dependency, alcoholism, pathological gambling, and nutrient addictions.

Poor Prognosis

We have come up to recognize today more than any other clip in history that the treatment of life style diseases and dependences are often a hard and frustrating undertaking for all concerned. Repeated failures abound with all of the addictions, even with utilizing the most effectual treatment strategies. But why make 47% of patients treated in private dependence treatment programmes (for example) backsliding within the first twelvemonth followers treatment (Gorski, T., 2001)? Rich Person dependence specializers go conditioned to accept failure as the norm? There are many grounds for this mediocre prognosis. Some would proclaim that dependences are psychosomatically- induced and maintained in a semi-balanced force field of drive and restraining multidimensional forces. Others would state that failures are owed simply to a deficiency of self-motivation Oregon will power. Most would hold that life style behavioural dependences are serious wellness hazards that rate our attention, but could it possibly be that patients with multiple dependences are being under diagnosed (with a single dependence) simply owed to a deficiency of diagnostic tools and resources that are incapable of resolving the complexness of assessing and treating a patient with multiple addictions?

Diagnostic Delineation

Thus far, the DSM-IV-TR have not delineated a diagnosing for the complexness of multiple behavioural and matter addictions. It have reserved the Poly-substance Dependence diagnosing for a individual who is repeatedly using at least three groupings of matters during the same 12-month period, but the criteria for this diagnosing make not affect any behavioural dependence symptoms. In the Psychological Factors Affecting Checkup Condition's subdivision (DSM-IV-TR, 2000) maladaptive wellness behaviours (e.g., insecure sexual practices, inordinate alcohol, drug use, and over eating, etc.) May be listed on Axis I, only if they are significantly affecting the course of study of treatment of a medical or mental condition.

Since successful treatment results are dependent on thorough assessments, accurate diagnoses, and comprehensive individualized treatment planning, it is no wonderment that perennial rehabilitation failures and low success rates are the norm instead of the exclusion in the dependences field, when the up-to-the-minute DSM-IV-TR makes not even include a diagnosing for multiple habit-forming behavioural disorders. Treatment clinics necessitate to have got a treatment planning system and referral web that is equipped to thoroughly measure multiple habit-forming and mental wellness upsets and related to treatment necessitates and comprehensively supply education/ awareness, bar scheme groups, and/ Oregon specific dependences treatment services for people diagnosed with multiple addictions. Written treatment ends and aims should be specified for each separate dependence and dimension of an individuals' life, and the desired public presentation result or completion criteria should be specifically stated, behaviorally based (a seeable activity), and measurable.

New Proposed Diagnosis

To help in resolving the limited DSM-IV-TRs' diagnostic capability, a multidimensional diagnosing of "Poly-behavioral Addiction," is proposed for more than than accurate diagnosing leading to more effectual treatment planning. This diagnosing encompasses the broadest class of habit-forming upsets that would include an individual manifesting a combination of matter maltreatment addictions, and other obsessively-compulsive behavioural habit-forming behavioural forms to pathological gambling, religion, and/ Oregon sexual activity / pornography, etc.). Behavioral dependences are just as detrimental - psychologically and socially as alcoholic beverage and drug abuse. They are comparative to other life-style diseases such as as diabetes, hypertension, and bosom disease in their behavioural manifestations, their etiologies, and their opposition to treatments. They are progressive upsets that affect obsessive thought and compulsive behaviors. They are also characterized by a preoccupation with a uninterrupted Oregon periodical loss of control, and uninterrupted irrational behaviour in malice of harmful consequences.

Poly-behavioral addiction would be described as a state of periodical or chronic physical, mental, emotional, cultural, sexual and/ or spiritual/ spiritual intoxication. These assorted types of poisoning are produced by perennial obsessive ideas and compulsive patterns involved in pathological human relationships to any mood-altering substance, person, organization, belief system, and/ Oregon activity. The individual have an overwhelming desire, demand Oregon irresistible impulse with the presence of a inclination to escalate their attachment to these practices, and grounds of phenomena of tolerance, abstention and withdrawal, in which there is always physical and/ or psychical dependance on the personal effects of this pathological relationship. In addition, there is a 12 - calendar month time period in which an individual is pathologically involved with three Oregon more than behavioural and/ or matter usage dependences simultaneously, but the criteria are not met for dependance for any 1 dependence in peculiar (Slobodzien, J., 2005). In essence, Poly-behavioral addiction is the synergistically incorporate chronic dependance on multiple physiologically habit-forming matters and behaviours (e.g., using/ abusing matters - nicotine, alcohol, & drugs, and/or acting impulsively Oregon obsessively compulsive in sees to gambling, nutrient binging, sex, and/ or religion, etc.) simultaneously.


Considering the broad scope of Negro spiritual behaviours in our human race today, one should always take into business relationship an individual's ethnic, cultural, spiritual, and societal background prior to making any clinical judgments, and it would be wise to not over-pathologize in this country of Religious Addiction. However, since successful treatment results are dependent on thorough assessments, accurate diagnoses, and comprehensive individualized treatment planning - poly-behavioral addiction necessitates to be identified to effectively handle the complexness of multiple behavioural and matter addictions.

Since chronic life style diseases and upsets such as as diabetes, hypertension, alcoholism, drug and behavioural dependences cannot be cured, but only managed - how should we effectively pull off poly-behavioral addiction?

The Addiction Recovery Measurement System (ARMS) is proposed utilizing a multidimensional integrative assessment, treatment planning, treatment progress, and treatment result measuring trailing system that facilitates rapid and accurate acknowledgment and rating of an individual's comprehensive life-functioning advancement dimensions. The weaponry hypothesis purports that there is a multidimensional synergistically negative opposition that individual's develop to any 1 word form of treatment to a single dimension of their lives, because the personal effects of an individual's addiction have got dynamically interacted multi-dimensionally. Having the primary focusing on one dimension is insufficient. Traditionally, dependence treatment programmes have got failed to suit for the multidimensional synergistically negative personal effects of an individual having multiple addictions, (e.g. nicotine, alcohol, and obesity, etc.). Behavioral dependences interact negatively with each other and with schemes to better overall functioning. They be given to advance the usage of tobacco, alcoholic beverage and other drugs, aid addition violence, lessening functional capacity, and promote societal isolation. Most treatment theories today affect assessing other dimensions to place double diagnosing or co-morbidity diagnoses, or to measure contributing factors that may play a function in the individual's primary addiction. The ARMS' theory proclaims that a multidimensional treatment program must be devised addressing the possible multiple dependences identified for each 1 of an individual's life dimensions in improver to developing specific ends and aims for each dimension.

Partnerships and coordination among service providers, authorities departments, and community organisations in providing dependence treatment programmes are a necessity in addressing the multi-task solution to poly-behavioral addiction. I promote you to back up the dependence programmes in America, and hope that the (ARMS) resources can help you to personally struggle the War on poly-behavioral addiction.

Poly-behavioral Addiction and the Addictions Recovery Measurement System (ARMS)

For more than information see: Aloha State and Christian Religious Addiction

Labels: , ,


Blogger karim said...

A valuable post on mental wellness.

Karim - Mind Power

September 28, 2009 at 10:01 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home